Murkowski faces real challenge in bid to be top GOP appropriator

Posted

Sen. Lisa Murkowski is facing a serious challenge in her bid to lead Republicans on the Appropriations Committee next year.

Many expected it to be a foregone conclusion that the Alaska lawmaker would succeed outgoing chair Susan Collins of Maine, who lost her reelection earlier this month; Murkowski is currently the most senior member of the GOP side of the committee dias eligible for a promotion.

But two Republican senators, granted anonymity to speak candidly, said they currently expect GOP members of the Senate Appropriations Committee to instead pick Sen. Jerry Moran (R-Kansas) as the party’s vice-chair.

“Moran will win,” said one of the senators in an interview Tuesday regarding the anticipated outcome of the committee vote.

Republicans on the Appropriations Committee won’t have the final say — and it’s still early in the discussions about who will get top Senate committee slots. But opting to effectively bless leapfrogging Murkowski in favor of Moran would be an astounding move for a conference that has long relied on seniority to determine who gets to lead the GOP on committees.

Republican appropriators will vote in January, once new GOP senators are added to the panel, for who they want leading them on the committee. That is, however, only a recommendation that has to then be upheld by the full Senate Republican Conference.

And it’s not clear, currently, how the full Senate GOP conference would handle a recommendation to set aside Murkowski as the top Republican on the panel, according to the two Senate Republicans as well as an additional GOP senator and two aides with knowledge of the matter — also granted anonymity to speak candidly given the sensitivity of the race.

The third senator said they weren’t yet sure who would win the vote among Appropriations Committee Republicans, but that they had advised Moran to “touch base with his leadership team … because the implications to losing a chairmanship also means bigger things for the conference.”

The ramifications, some Republicans worry, could involve a scenario where more GOP senators feel empowered to challenge more senior members for committee leadership spots, prompting open warfare as the party is still trying to regroup after a bruising election cycle. It would also just mark a deviation from the way the conference typically does business — though the conference rules don’t require that the top spot for a committee also be the most senior member.

Senate Majority Leader John Thune said last week he hadn’t yet weighed into the dispute between Murkowski and Moran but that he had advised them to “talk it out” and that “we’ll see where those conversations lead.”

Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), a member of leadership and a high-ranking appropriator, said Tuesday she didn’t know what the outcome of the contest would be but that Murkowski and Moran will meet this week.

Murkowski and Moran have in the meantime both been privately meeting with, and making the case to, colleagues. Spokespeople for neither of the two GOP senators provided a request for comment Tuesday.

Moran did not articulate to POLITICO last week a reason for why he would challenge Murkowski. She will, however, be the most moderate GOP senator remaining come January, and has broken with her party on numerous high-profile decisions over the years.

Democrats also view Murkowski as someone they could potentially negotiate with on government spending deals but are staying out of the GOP dispute.

“Boy, that’s an [intra]party fight on that side. You know, I would have to say on our side that would be really hard, where somebody who’s done all the work and moved their way up — but that’s their neighborhood,” Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.), who will chair the committee next year, said in an interview.

Also potentially working to Murkowski’s disadvantage is that Republicans will be losing five senators on the Appropriations Committee come January, many of whom would have likely been Murkowski allies. It’s not yet clear who will get their spots and who Murkowski and Moran will need to win over.

And even as Republicans grapple with Murkowski’s fate, they appear poised to let GOP senators who have infuriated their colleagues over the past year hold top committee spots. Sens. Mike Lee of Utah and Rand Paul of Kentucky — two notorious thorns in leadership’s side — are, respectively, on tap to be ranking members on the Judiciary Committee and the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions panel.

Neither man currently has a challenger seeking to bypass the seniority system.

Congress, DC, Lisa Murkowski, Jerry Moran, Susan Collins, Appropriations, Senate Appropriations Committee, John Thune, Shelley Moore Capito, Patty Murray, Rand Paul, Mike Lee